Do you think Guns n Roses are still just as good as they were when they first started out?

-Q1: What's ur fave Gunners album? Why?

Q2: Do you think they've changed for the worst since the departure of the original line-up (Izzy, Slash, Adler, Duff)?

Q3: What is your opinion of their latest album, Chinese Democracy?

Q4: What do you think of the newest addition, guitarist, DJ Ashba?



They've definately changed a lot, but i still think they're just as great now as they were when they started out 26 years ago. Axl is a fighter and every true fan knows he wouldn't let his band die without a fight. Long live Gunners!!1 - Appetite For Destruction.. I love the UYI albums and Lies, but AFD is just a pure classic.. caught them at their most volatile

2 - Yes.. definitely. Guns N Roses now just doesn't compare, they didn't release an album for over a decade, and Axl is an even bigger idiot than he was just before the original lineup disbanded.

3 - I actually really like Chinese Democracy.. but it just isn't Guns N Roses.. it doesn't have that feel to it, and it features far to many musicians due to crazy lineup changes. It's more like an Axl and friends album than a GNR album.

4 - He's a good guitarist but I haven't heard him live with GNR and there hasn't been any material released yet with him playing, so I can't judge.



Essentially they just aren't really GNR now. They disbanded in the mid 90's, stayed quiet for over a decade and then finally released another album with a completely different lineup (bar Axl). You may say that he's never gonna let the band die, but in my opinion he kinda killed what GNR actually is/was back in the 90's. Today's GNR is a completely different band that has just emerged suddenly, out of nothing.. and it's a great shame. Saying that though, I would love to hear some more new material.. they're not a bad band afterall, they're just not the GNR most fans knew and loved.No ******* way!

I wouldn't call it Guns N Roses... just The Axl Rose Band.



1) Use Your Illusion II... the songs on it are all ace, minus My World, but hey. :)

2) Yes, I do.

拢) Crap, but there are one or two good songs.

4) Stupid. He should stop calling himself DJ Ashba. It sounds ridiculous for somebody in a rock band.
Q1: Appetite for Destruction

Q2: They've changed, they're not as good IMO, but they're still good.

Q3: I really like it, it's no Appetite, but Axl never said he was gonna make another Appetite style album

Q4: He's good, I like him, he suits the band
Good, but not as good.



1. Appetite For Destruction becuase uh...I like the songs best?

2. Yeah.

3. Alright, but didn't live up to the hype or to my own expectations.

4. Eh.
Greatest hits

still like them but they were better

Havent listened to it yet

hate swapping the originals but hes good so its nto to bad
Appetite For Destruction , the best music i have ever heard

yes , they are worst now

(i hate axl rose)

he is a loser
Use Your Illusion II - Because it has songs like Get In The Ring, 14 Years and Breakdown.

Yes a lot.

It sucked big time.

Don't like him.
hmm their still good

don't really listen to them I only listen to slipknot and marilyn manson :)

didn't hear

bleh
I would say they're just as bad.
Nope, Axl is the only original left and to me that makes the music sound way different like its a new band (which it is) but it just doesn't have the same feel.



1- Tie between Appetite For Destruction which I love because it was such a hard rock album, crunchy distortion, sick guitar solos, heavy drums n bass etc I also think it was some of Axls best work vocally. That album ties with Use Your Illusion II, with some amazing songs like Estranged and So Fine and Civil War I think those songs were some of the bands more meaningful songs.



2- I think the newer Gnr is still good, I personally dont like it as much as the original band, like I said before it just has that different feel to it, which is not a bad thing. Just personal opinion.



3- I think its not too bad, has a few good songs on there, good on Axl for putting out new material and decent stuff as well, I agree on him being a fighter part.



4- Eh, it sounds like he should a hip hop or rap artist not in a rock band, but he's not a bad guitarist I've heard a lot worse :P